Annulment is a legal process that essentially wipes a marriage off the books, making it as if it never existed. But what if you’re still legally married—maybe because of a previous, unresolved marriage or some other legal mix-up? The answer isn’t always straightforward.
Let’s say you unknowingly married someone who was already legally married. In that case, your marriage might be automatically void due to bigamy—meaning it was never valid in the first place. You wouldn’t need an annulment because, legally speaking, the marriage never existed. But if you’re the one still married to someone else, things get trickier. Before seeking an annulment for your current marriage, you’d likely need to deal with the first one—usually through divorce.
Annulment laws vary by state, and Arizona has specific rules about when an annulment applies. Grounds like fraud, coercion, or incapacity may qualify, but simply realizing you’re “still married” usually isn’t enough. If you’re facing this situation, speaking with a family law attorney can help you understand your options.
Next, let’s break down what qualifies as an annulment and how it differs from divorce.
What Is an Annulment?
An annulment is a legal ruling that essentially erases a marriage, treating it as if it never happened. Unlike divorce, which ends a valid marriage, an annulment declares that the union was never legally sound in the first place. This distinction matters because it can affect everything from property rights to financial obligations.
Legal Definition of Annulment
For a marriage to be annulled, there must be solid legal grounds proving it was never valid to begin with. Courts typically grant annulments in cases involving fraud, coercion, bigamy, or other serious legal violations. If you suspect your marriage falls into one of these categories, it’s important to check your state’s specific annulment laws, as they can vary widely.
How an Annulment Differs from Divorce
While both annulments and divorces dissolve marriages, they do so in very different ways. A divorce acknowledges that a legitimate marriage existed but has now ended—usually due to irreconcilable differences or other legal grounds. An annulment, on the other hand, wipes the slate clean by declaring the marriage invalid from the start.
Because annulments require specific legal proof, they’re often harder to obtain than divorces. They can also impact property division and spousal support differently, which is why having a solid understanding of your options is crucial.
If you’re wondering whether your situation qualifies for an annulment, knowing what counts as valid grounds is the next step. Let’s take a closer look at what circumstances might make you eligible.
Grounds for Annulment
Fraud, Misrepresentation, or Deception
One of the most common reasons for annulment is fraud. If your spouse misled you about something fundamental—like already being married, lying about wanting children, or marrying you just to get a green card—you might have grounds for an annulment. Courts take these cases seriously because marriage is built on trust. Unlike divorce, which ends a legal marriage, an annulment wipes it off the books as if it never happened.
Bigamy or Pre-Existing Marriage
You can’t legally marry someone who’s already married—it’s that simple. If your spouse was still legally tied to someone else when you got married, your marriage is automatically void. This is called bigamy, and it’s illegal in every state. While an annulment may seem automatic in this case, you’ll still need to go through the legal process to make it official. If you recently discovered that your spouse had another marriage on the books, getting legal guidance should be your next step.
Lack of Consent or Capacity
Marriage requires full understanding and consent from both people involved. If one of you was intoxicated, coerced, or mentally incapable of making such a commitment at the time of the wedding, the marriage may not be valid. Imagine waking up after a wild night in Vegas only to realize you got married—if you were too impaired to understand what was happening, an annulment could undo that mistake. More serious cases involve mental illness or cognitive impairment, where one person simply wasn’t capable of agreeing to the marriage in the first place.
Underage or Forced Marriage
If someone got married without meeting the legal age requirement and didn’t have parental or court approval, they might qualify for an annulment. Similarly, if a person was pressured or forced into a marriage they never wanted, courts are likely to declare it invalid. No one should be forced into a lifelong commitment against their will—the law recognizes that and provides annulments as a way out in these situations.
Understanding these grounds is key when considering an annulment. But what if you’re still legally married? Let’s explore what that means next.
Can You Get an Annulment While Still Married?
Trying to figure out whether you can get an annulment while still legally married? It’s a tricky situation, and the answer depends on the circumstances. In most cases, an annulment is used to declare a marriage invalid—as if it never legally existed. But what if you find out your spouse was already married to someone else? Or that your own marriage was never legally recognized in the first place? Let’s break it down.
Understanding Bigamy Laws
If you’re still legally married to someone else, your second marriage isn’t just questionable—it’s void under the law. In Arizona (and most other states), bigamy—being married to more than one person at the same time—is illegal. That means your second marriage never had legal standing in the first place. So, technically, you don’t need an annulment because there’s nothing valid to annul. However, even though the law sees it as void, you might still need to take legal steps to clear things up, especially when dealing with finances or family matters.
Legal Implications of Being Married to Two People
Even if a second marriage is automatically void due to bigamy, it doesn’t mean you can just walk away without consequences. There are still important legal and financial issues to sort out:
– Any property acquired during the invalid marriage could still be subject to legal disputes.
– If you have children together, custody and child support arrangements will need to be made official.
– Without a court ruling, your marital status could remain unclear, leading to complications later on.
If you’re unsure about where you stand legally, speaking with a family law attorney is a smart move. They can help you figure out whether you need an annulment or if another legal process—like divorce or separation—is the better route.
How to File for an Annulment
Filing for an annulment isn’t as simple as just signing a few papers—it’s a legal process that requires careful steps. If you think your marriage qualifies, here’s how to get started.
Step 1: Determine Eligibility
First things first—do you actually meet the legal grounds for an annulment? Not every unhappy marriage qualifies. Courts typically grant annulments in cases of fraud, bigamy, lack of consent, or one spouse being underage at the time of marriage. If you’re unsure whether your situation meets the criteria, it’s worth speaking with a family law attorney before moving forward.
Step 2: Gather Necessary Documentation
Annulments require proof, so gathering the right paperwork is key. You’ll likely need:
– A copy of your marriage certificate
– Evidence supporting your claim (like proof of fraud or bigamy)
– Any relevant emails, texts, or witness statements
– Identification documents
The stronger your evidence, the smoother the process will be. If you have trouble finding certain documents, an attorney can help track them down.
Step 3: File a Petition with the Court
Once you’ve got everything in order, it’s time to file a petition for annulment at your local family court. This document explains why the marriage should be legally erased. Be prepared—there may be filing fees, and if your spouse disagrees with the annulment, they can contest it, which could complicate things.
Step 4: Attend a Court Hearing
In most cases, a judge will review your petition and schedule a hearing. This is where you’ll present your evidence and explain why the marriage should be annulled. Your spouse may also have a chance to respond. If everything checks out, the judge will issue an order declaring the marriage null and void—like it never happened.
Not sure about any of this? That’s completely normal. A family law attorney can walk you through the process and make sure you’re on solid legal ground. Up next, let’s talk about some challenges you might face when seeking an annulment.
Challenges in Obtaining an Annulment
Proving Grounds for Annulment
One of the toughest parts of getting an annulment is proving that your marriage was never legally valid in the first place. Courts won’t grant one just because you regret getting married or feel like it was a mistake. You have to show solid proof—documents, witness statements, or other clear evidence—that something was legally wrong from the start. If you’re claiming fraud, for example, you’ll need to demonstrate that your spouse deliberately deceived you about something essential to the marriage. Without strong evidence, the court may reject your case.
Spouse Contests the Annulment
Things can get even trickier if your spouse doesn’t agree to the annulment. When both partners are on the same page, the process is usually straightforward. But if your spouse fights it, you could end up in a long and stressful legal battle. They might argue that there was no fraud or that you willingly entered into the marriage, making it harder for you to prove otherwise. In these situations, having an experienced attorney on your side can make all the difference.
State-Specific Limitations
Annulment laws aren’t the same everywhere, and some states have stricter rules than others. In Arizona, for example, there are specific conditions you must meet, and waiting too long to file could mean losing your chance altogether. Some grounds—like fraud—require showing that you only recently discovered the deception. If too much time has passed, a judge may decide that you had plenty of time to act and deny your request.
If an annulment isn’t possible due to these challenges, don’t worry—there are other legal options available. Next, we’ll look at what happens after an annulment and how it affects things like property division and child custody.
What Happens After an Annulment?
An annulment legally wipes a marriage off the books—at least in the eyes of the law. But what does that actually mean for things like property, children, and financial obligations? Let’s break it down.
Impact on Property and Assets
Since an annulment treats the marriage as if it never happened, there isn’t a typical division of assets like you’d see in a divorce. Instead, both parties usually walk away with whatever they brought into the marriage. But what if you combined bank accounts or bought a home together? That’s where things can get tricky. In some cases, a judge might step in to make sure things are divided fairly, especially if one spouse was financially dependent on the other or if fraud played a role.
Effects on Child Custody and Support
A big misconception about annulments is that they erase parental responsibilities—they don’t. If you have children together, the court will still need to determine custody, visitation, and child support, just like in a divorce. The kids’ best interests always come first, no matter how the marriage ended.
Does an Annulment Erase the Marriage Record?
Not exactly. While an annulment makes it legally as if your marriage never existed, the records don’t just disappear. You’ll still have official documents showing both the marriage and its annulment. That said, once it’s finalized, you’re legally considered single again—just as if the marriage never happened.
If you’re unsure how an annulment affects your situation, talking to a family law attorney can help clear up any confusion and guide you through your next steps.
Alternatives if You Don’t Qualify for an Annulment
Divorce as an Option
If an annulment isn’t in the cards for you, divorce is usually the next best route. Unlike an annulment, which wipes a marriage off the record as if it never happened, divorce legally ends a valid marriage. That means you’ll need to sort out issues like property division, spousal support, and child custody—all of which can have lasting impacts.
The good news? Arizona is a no-fault divorce state, meaning you don’t have to prove wrongdoing. If your marriage is “irretrievably broken,” that’s enough. A divorce can also provide important legal protections. For instance, if your spouse was the primary breadwinner, you may qualify for spousal maintenance (alimony)—something you likely wouldn’t get with an annulment. And if you share children, the court will establish parenting time and child support to protect their best interests.
Legal Separation
Not ready to take the full leap into divorce? Legal separation allows couples to live apart while remaining legally married. Some choose this option for religious reasons or to keep benefits like health insurance intact. It covers many of the same legal matters as divorce—child custody, asset division, and financial support—without fully dissolving the marriage.
Deciding between annulment, divorce, or separation isn’t easy. Talking to a family law attorney can help clarify your options so you can move forward with confidence.
FAQs About Marriage Annulments
Does an annulment erase a marriage record?
Not exactly. An annulment makes a marriage legally void, meaning it’s treated as if it never happened—but that doesn’t mean it disappears from all records. The marriage will still show up in certain legal documents, but instead of being marked as dissolved by divorce, it will be listed as annulled.
How long do I have to file for an annulment?
It depends. Some states have strict deadlines depending on the reason for annulment. If fraud or misrepresentation is involved, you may only have a limited time to act. But in cases like bigamy, where one spouse was already married, you can usually file at any time.
Can my spouse contest an annulment?
Yes, and it happens more often than you’d think. If your spouse argues that the marriage was valid, the court will review the details before making a decision. Having a knowledgeable family law attorney can make all the difference in proving your case.
Leave a Reply